The Good Life

What’s Your Favorite Movie?

| By Garrett Rutledge | From The Movie Issue, May/June 2023
What’s Your Favorite Movie?

It’s one of those typical questions that’s leaned on in moments of conversational gridlock or introductory icebreakers: “What’s your favorite movie?” We can’t help but be drawn in by the question’s revelation of personality and taste, so naturally when we at Cigar Aficionado dedicated a cover package to the movies, we wanted to know our readers’ favorites. 

We sent out a poll to a random group of readers to get a feel for what you like, and it elicited some intriguing results, both expected and unexpected.

Movie Poll
Casablanca (1942)

The Godfather was voted No. 1 by a landslide, taking 25.1 percent of all votes, and we can’t say we’re all that surprised. After all, our 2022 March/April issue featured a cover of Vito Corleone with the headline “The 50th Anniversary of the Greatest Film Ever Made.” The Godfather: Part II also drew votes, but didn’t fare as well, named by 1.3 percent of voters as their favorite. 

The 1942 classic Casablanca has a firm hold as the second-highest vote getter, with 6.2 percent. Two films from the 1990s, Goodfellas and The Shawshank Redemption, were neck-and-neck in third and fourth place, respectively (3.1 percent and 2.6 percent). Tied in fourth place was Academy Award-winner The Sting.

Rounding out our top vote getters were several fan favorites, including Gladiator, Tombstone and the World War II epic The Longest Day. The Tom Cruise blockbuster Top Gun and the Al Pacino/Robert DeNiro film Heat also drew votes.

Movie Poll
The Sting (1973)

Interestingly, there are more movies near the top of this list that are at least 50 years old than there are films from our present century. A classic is a classic for a reason, right? 

Your Favorites

1 - The Godfather (25.1%) 

2 - Casablanca (6.2%) 

3 - Goodfellas (3.1%) 

4 - The Shawshank RedemptionThe Sting (2.6%)

6 - GladiatorTombstone (1.8%)

8 - The Godfather: Part II; Heat; The Longest Day (1.3%)

This poll only reflected a small portion of our readers, so we want to hear from you as well. Go to cigaraficionado.com/moviesurvey and tell us your favorite!

the-good-life

More in The Good Life

See all
Cigar Aficionado’s 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

Cigar Aficionado’s 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

Consider this compendium of tangible, masculine delights in a range of categories and prices.

Dec 4, 2023
Alabama Exacts Revenge Over Tennessee, Celebrates With Cigars

Alabama Exacts Revenge Over Tennessee, Celebrates With Cigars

Alabama got the last laugh in the "Third Saturday in October" rivalry this weekend, bringing out the …

Oct 23, 2023
Viking Polaris Sails To Antarctica With Nordic Flair

Viking Polaris Sails To Antarctica With Nordic Flair

Viking’s Polaris expedition ship offers a 13-day voyage with six days exploring the frozen continent …

Oct 22, 2023
A Sunroom Turned Cigar Hangout In Chicago

A Sunroom Turned Cigar Hangout In Chicago

Filip Jakubek of Tinley Park, Illinois took matters into his own hands when creating his idyllic …

Oct 12, 2023
A 1938 French Roadster Takes Top Honors At Newport Car Show

A 1938 French Roadster Takes Top Honors At Newport Car Show

Newport, Rhode Island was car central last week, as the annual Audrain Newport Concours & Motor …

Oct 6, 2023
The Paolo Martorano Jacket

The Paolo Martorano Jacket

They say the clothes make the man, and few make finer jackets than Paolo Martorano, a cigar-smoking …

Sep 29, 2023